It works in the lab. Give product management a business case they can approve.
Evidence from users and the market, and a prototype people can try.
Step 1 · the idea. What works in the lab, written as a user's problem. Who has the problem, and what changes for them once it's solved.
Step 2 · users. Conversations with the people who would use it. How many have the problem, what they do about it today, and what they'd give up for a fix.
Step 3 · market. How big the need is, and who already serves it. Each number carries its label: measured, estimated or not known.
Step 4 · prototype. A prototype people can try. We watch what users do with it, and report where it fails too.
Step 5 · the case. The case, written for the people who decide the roadmap. The evidence, the prototype results, the cost and the ask, on a few pages.
Evidence that shows the trade-offs, including where an idea didn't help.
Published · Walmart Labs. Shoppers added more to their carts in three of four categories, and slightly less for laptops. About → The paper reports the drop next to the gains. arXiv 1811.07996; Causal-impact analysis over 3 weeks
Internal · design record. From the need, to the requirement, to the trade-off accepted. Written down for each design decision in our own product.
Internal · design record. A prepackaged report first, then the user asks open questions where they see a gap. The cost is on the record too: a new fixed indicator takes at least two days, and open answers can be wrong, so a professional reviews them.
Walmart · internal funding won. The research and the business case persuaded Walmart executives to fund the project. The same method helps you make the case to product management.